Bear Lake is famous for its jaw-dropping turquoise waters, epic outdoor adventures, and delicious raspberry shakes. But there’s something else that puts this scenic getaway on the map — a legendary creature said to lurk beneath the lake’s surface.
For over 150 years, stories have swirled about a giant beast that moves faster than a speeding boat and occasionally pops up to terrify unsuspecting visitors. Some say it’s a giant sea serpent-like creature with glowing red eyes; others describe it as a massive, water-spouting beast that could outrun a speeding boat.
Is this Bear Lake Monster just a quirky urban legend, or is there something real lurking beneath the waves? Let’s dive into the mystery and find out!
How the Legend of the Bear Lake Monster Got Started
In 1868, a writer named Joseph C. Rich sent an article to the Deseret News, claiming that Indigenous tribes had long spoken of a “water devil” that lived in Bear Lake. His article detailed first-hand and second-hand accounts from settlers who said they had seen a giant serpent-like creature inhabiting the lake and slicing through the water at alarming speeds.
The Descriptions of the Bear Lake Monster Varied:
- Some said it had the head of a cow, while others swore it looked like an alligator or walrus (minus the tusks, of course).
- A few claimed it had stubby legs that helped it crawl onto shore (which, if true, is just nightmare fuel).
- Most agreed it was long, fast, and terrifying.
Understandably, the story caused a frenzy. People flocked to the lake, hoping to spot the beast. Even Brigham Young himself got involved, sending a large rope to help capture it.
What did they plan to do with it if they caught it? Who knows.
Then, twenty-six years later, Rich admitted he made the whole thing up.
Oops.
But here’s the thing – even after he confessed, the sightings didn’t stop.
The Sightings That Keep the Mystery Alive
Even though the legend started as a joke, many Bear Lake people kept seeing something in the lake.
- In 1907, two men claimed the monster attacked their camp and killed one of their horses.
- A four-year-old in 1937 saw something weird in the water (and let’s be honest, kids don’t usually lie about monsters).
- In 1946, a Boy Scout leader swore he saw a massive creature swimming beneath the surface.
- The most recent sighting? 2002, when a local business owner described a two-humped beast with slimy skin and glowing red eyes.
Is it just driftwood? A really big fish? A trick of the light? Maybe. But then again…maybe not.
Is the Bear Lake Monster Real or a Myth?
So, what’s the deal? Is there a prehistoric lake beast lurking in Bear Lake Valley, or is this just overactive imaginations?
Here are some Theories for Our Monster Friend in Bear Lake Valley
- Optical Illusions: Waves, floating logs, and even large fish can create shadows and movements that look monstrous from a distance.
- Giant Sturgeon Theory: Some believe the Bear Lake Monster could be a massive sturgeon, a fish known for its dinosaur-like appearance and impressive size.
- Cultural Storytelling: From Loch Ness Monster to Lake Champlain’s Champ, nearly every deep lake has a monster story. The legend of the Bear Lake Monster might just be Northern Utah’s answer to Nessie!
Could this monster be real? That’s for you to decide! Whether a cryptid, an oversized fish, or just a fun bit of local lore, the Bear Lake Monster has become an unforgettable part of the region’s charm.
Celebrating the Bear Lake Monster Today
Whether you’re a believer in the monster or just love a good legend, the Bear Lake Monster is a beloved part of local culture. The community has fully embraced the creature, incorporating it into festivals, business names, and tourist attractions.
- Annual Raspberry Days Festival: Each year, Garden City hosts a float in its Annual Raspberry Days Festival parade labeled “The Real Bear Lake Monsters,” featuring local kids enjoying the fun.
- Bear Lake Monster Winterfest: This event celebrates the legend with a thrilling polar plunge, monster-themed cardboard boat races, and other winter activities.
- The Bear Lake Monster Boat: Once a popular attraction, this dragon-shaped boat took visitors on folklore-filled cruises across Bear Lake.
And if you visit local shops, don’t be surprised to find souvenirs, artwork, and plush toys paying homage to Isabella — the bear lake monster’s name, chosen by an eight-year-old girl during a community contest in 1996.
Plan Your Trip to Bear Lake
Isabella may or may not make an appearance, but Bear Lake’s stunning views, outdoor adventures, and charming local culture guarantee a trip to remember. Whether you’re visiting for a family vacation, a romantic getaway, or just to chase down a legendary monster, Bear Lake Premier Cabins offers the top vacation rentals for your adventure.
And who knows – maybe you’ll be the next person to catch a glimpse of something strange beneath the waves.
Just…maybe don’t go swimming alone. You know, just in case.
Book your stay today and come experience the magic of Bear Lake for yourself!
